Cook Islands is in my bottom3. No one was really likeable and worth rooting for plus the idol twist is too much. I think you either love or hate the season, but i thought it was a snoozefest.
Cook Islands isn't ranked that low for me, but I really did think it was pretty boring. Yul was a great player, but obviously, if you're looking for entertainment, that's another thing. The race twist caused a bunch of recruitment that wasn't necessary and gave us bores. Sundra, Becky, Brad, Rebecca, and Jenny were some of the most underedited players ever, and that's a lot for one season. I feel like people just like some of its most memorable players such as Penner, Yul, Ozzy, & Parvati (I think Billy is more liked than Candice, who was just really liked by Production & Co.) and their presence makes the season overrated.
I just wish they would let someone from Guatemala come back, and then people can go back to remembering that Guatemala really was just a middle-tier season.